I have been away for too long and a lot has happened. Given the events of the past couple months I think it might be time for me to observe and prognosticate. Get an extra cup of coffee fans of my blog (BOTH of you), Sean is going to bloviate a bit.
Let me preface my remarks by saying that I still believe The Cato Institute was correct in their report that
“W” was the worst violator of The Constitution of all Presidents. I’m going to rant about my concern for the Obama administration, but at least what’s happening is in plain site (most of it)…Dubbya engaged in secretive, nefarious actions in the name of “national security”; which is becoming one of the most overused & specious reasons for legislation I can think of.
That being said, I am very nervous of the current administration’s recent actions for a couple reasons:
A) Legislation that is being passed is big now and promises to become bigger in the future and
B) The legislation presents itself as “helping American’s” at a time when America is panicking. Big government stepping in during times of panic usually leads to bigger government even after everyone has calmed down (i.e
PATRIOT act).
Consider the week after nationalized health care passed. After the “big vote” passed on Sunday, by the end of the business week we also had legislation in place for the government to completely
takeover student loans and have a
bigger role in covering mortgages. So in less than a week the government now has a primary role in the health, education and housing of the citizenry. Let’s play one of my favorite games: Reductio ad absurdum.
Healthcare: Let’s not quibble about every element of the
1900+ page law. Regardless of how it closes the Medicare donut hole, if you get to keep your current insurance plan or if it’s even constitutional to force citizens to purchase…Anything; let’s boil it down to just those who will gladly take the government plan. As our elected officials want to be diligent with taxpayer dollars I have to assume at some point they will require those on the public dole to take a baseline physical and some blood work. What if the results don’t come out so good? Do we let those on the public plan keep eating Big Mac’s and have taxpayers simply keep buying the Tricor® for them? I say we make that person start eating only fruits, vegetables and grains. Of course, the recipient will howl that we are violating their rights by mandating what they eat and how they exercise, but I say (and so should a fiscally responsible government official) why should taxpayers have to keep supporting an unhealthy lifestyle? So I ask the voter, on this one simple issue, does the government get to direct your lifestyle when you’re on public health insurance or does the taxpayer have to pay for the continued unhealthy lifestyle of others? One or the other here. You decide. And that is one of the SIMPLE considerations to government takeover of health care! Oh by the way, if you did read that law you will notice that it says in the subtitle that it's supposed provide affordable, quality health care "and for other purposes". No pork there, I'm sure.
Student Loans: Ok, real simple here. Go to the
Department of Labor web site and you can see all sorts of statistics about who works what and where we have shortages of this profession or that. Imagine this; you decide you want to start or finish your degree in…Oh, say…Political Science. You’re trying to make ends meet and just don’t have the extra cash to pay for tuition so you apply for a student loan with the centralized Department of Education, filling out the requisite documents and divulging what your major is going to be. However, the government has determined that there is a glut in all professions tied to a Political Science degree (lawyer, social studies teacher…Congressman) so, unless you change your major to one in which there is more demand for the associated profession, the funds can not be granted. I mean, there are only so many dollars available so we have to spend them where they’ll do the most good, right? “
You can’t make me study what I don’t want or am weak in” you strongly protest! “
We can if you want public money” is the form letter response. Think this is a silly thought? Inquire with the
MESC on what are considered by the State of Michigan as “qualified” training programs for the unemployed who seek tuition assistance while unemployed. Basically it boils down to being a truck driver or a nurse.
Mortgages: This one is tricky to predict, but there will probably be some formula to determine how much you can borrow based on income with the equation being skewed by those that abused the private sector system in the past…er…Excuse me, I mean those who were victims of “predatory lending” while accepting a mortgage on a five bedroom house while earning honest income as a clerk in a party store. Anyhoo, I imagine if one hands their mortgage over to the government a couple fun mandates will kick in. First, you probably have to meet every random code established by whatever alphabet-soup agency at the federal level requires…Not to mention meeting state code(s). Also, as your mortgage is sitting in the hands of taxpayers, if you so much as paint your garage (thereby increasing the value, which makes you even more rich) then you SHALL report it to your mortgage holder for a new value/tax assessment. Not doing so, of course, would put you in violation of federal law. My vision seems a little over-the-top I know, until you speak with a current homeowner about what tax & code issues they go through at the local level; and their local government isn’t holding the mortgage!
These are my predictions effective April 2010; only time will tell. You may think my perspectives are a bit excessive, but I challenge you to show me one government action that has either gotten smaller or been removed over time; we still have a
Bureau of Indian Affairs and I think that was formed about the time Gen. Custer committed a tactical faux pas for crying out loud! If we don’t reconsider our current course of handing every aspect our life over to the federal government we may find that what started out as a safe embrace turns into a hug delivered by Lennie Small!
Labels: entitlements, government takeover, health care